Формат | Размер | Скачать |
---|
Название | : | |
Продолжительность | : | |
Пользователь | : | id 711899623382 |
Дата публикации | : | ript src= |
Просмотры | : | layer\/3b96d06c\/www-embed-player.vflset\/www-embed-player.js |
Понравилось | : | 1,465 |
Не понравилось | : | 51 |
So what modern bands do you believe embody the spirit of gothic rock? Trash Theory playlists - Spotify: tinyurl.com/yxp32pjf Deezer: tinyurl.com/y2mdp8h2 Also if you want to help out, here's my patreon link: patreon.com/trashtheory Комментарий от : @TrashTheory |
When you enshroud yourself with classic literature. Комментарий от : @JustinGreenewald |
No mention of Screaming Lord Sutch? Surely the first English goth Комментарий от : @user-rr6nb3jv9r |
i always been attracted to goth rock music but for me it started in the 90s after MTV's 120 minutes. i probably was the ONLY one in my NYC urban neighborhood who loves that kind of music 🖤💖💜 Комментарий от : @roguedolltherebelbi-ch3190 |
"Real Goths don't wear back. They sack Rome." Favorite T-shirt phrase o date. PS. Manson himself made clear (and when you comprehend the modern style properly) isn't "Goth." In fact there are several such bands" that have been "labeled" goth because of lazy promoters despite the bands considering themselves more punk, emo, freak, metal, etc. Комментарий от : @talismanskulls2857 |
Et l'iguane? Il mérite sa place Комментарий от : @jean-pierrepurcha9327 |
Don’t forget that early heavy metal like Black Sabbath and Led Zeppelin brought in and conventionalized a dark mystique vibe in music. More innovative in many ways than people realize. Not disregarding the early punk and goth subcultures either. Комментарий от : @carpenoctem775 |
It all comes back to iggy pop Комментарий от : @SubparLoki |
This really contextualized my coming of age in Goth-Punk Washington DC in the 1980s and 1990s. Комментарий от : @dcseain |
OK. I had to stop watching this when you said Alice Cooper portrayed Stage Suicide!?? He Never did. There was the Hanging Stunt and The Beheading. All done by an aggressor. Never Suicide. Do your research mate. This is not Goth at all! Комментарий от : @rossmunro7084 |
Why is not the UK trend setting into the 21stC? 60s70s80s90s ...& then...nothing. Комментарий от : @salinagrrrl69 |
J'ai toujours cru que c'était Siouxie qui avait créé ce style musical. Комментарий от : @MrJeepsters |
Although I Hate Goths this Documentary is interesting Комментарий от : @leonshackleford9585 |
Sisters of Mercy should have featured far more in this. Other bands like the Mission, Spear of Destiny and the Cult didn’t feature at all. What were the Cramps doing in there? Комментарий от : @paulhaskey5295 |
Yes but who was the 1st big tiddy goth girl? 😂❤ Комментарий от : @ramcharger154 |
You might have overlooked Johc Cale... a lot :D Комментарий от : @merzbow12 |
You forgot that goth is also extreme daddy issues Комментарий от : @mattias969 |
Goth forever. It's a state of being. Not a fashion or trend. Комментарий от : @imago9059 |
One day someone will get even bit about Goth will get it write unlike this video Bowie /Roxy etc was Glam Rock Комментарий от : @woody5831 |
THE DAMNED Комментарий от : @darrenpaches3731 |
I would never really consider Marilyn Manson or Alice Cooper goth lol. Shock rock? Sure. But the spirit is a bit different Комментарий от : @CODENAMECRISISOFFICIAL |
I was goth in high school but it wasnt a thing. I was just depressed and seeking out deathly music. By the tine goth was a thing I had moved on to what later became raver fashion, for which I was now too old LOL I still don't dress like anyone else and if they copird me I eould change. Viva la difference! Комментарий от : @1st1anarkissed |
Yet again Japan get missed out. Their first two albums Adolescent Sex and Obscure Alternatives were simultaneous to punk but definitely fit the goth genre. Mick Karn looked the part too. Комментарий от : @Banglish123 |
Every once in a while I drive a lap of Toronto - 401, 427, DVP & Gardiner Exp. I play my BBC recording of Bela Lugosi's Dead to start the trip and at the end of the trip. It's a good drive. Комментарий от : @andrewanderson5297 |
Excellent video. Комментарий от : @DrSimonBignell |
Audience did "I put a spell on you". Комментарий от : @DanielESmith-iz7lx |
Great video Cheers friend! Комментарий от : @Ihad9eyes |
I like your subject matter, but the voice over throughout the pieces is uninspiring. Just my opinion Комментарий от : @feedboy2112 |
I have no idea why on earth would you state My Chemical Romance as being part of the gothic sub genre. They are 💯% an EMO band through and through, ask any purist who was a teenager during their time in the mid 2000s who was 14+. It's madness that you would have Marilyn Manson and My Chemical Romance in the same damn sentence, when they were fulling f'n beefing with each other at the height of MCR during the Black Parade album. MM's own words " “I’m embarrassed to be me because these people are doing a really sad, pitiful, shallow version of what I’ve done. If they want to identify with me then here’s a razor blade. Call me when you’re done and we’ll talk.". Either your ignorant AF of actual gothic music during that time or just some Gen-Z poser, I was actually in High School when MM's "Eat Me Drink Me" came out so I know wtf I am talking about! Nme. “My Chemical Romance Respond to Marilyn Manson Jibes.” NME, 11 June 2007, www.nme.com/news/music/my-chemical-romance-147-1337495. Комментарий от : @syedzaidi6606 |
Fantastic!!!! Oh this really brings me back to the old days. Soil in San Diego was my first goth club. I was totally underage, but I looked like 25 so I always managed to get in anyway. Anyone here remember that tiny place? Комментарий от : @repeatdefender6032 |
Why No 69 eyes reference??? Комментарий от : @crow4936 |
You missed out SPF 1000 manson ripped them off for most of his early sound Комментарий от : @crow4936 |
I've used Bela lugosis dead as a work out song for years. Комментарий от : @ReachSkyla |
The Cramps, inspired the Russian group! Messer Shups 😬 Комментарий от : @frankmartinez4856 |
Hey Trash Theory did you know that Procol Harum’s Whiter Shade of Pale and Moody Blues Nights In White Satin count as Proto-Goth Rock songs Комментарий от : @logandockery1512 |
Billy eilish Комментарий от : @jimlee1612 |
omg this is way too good 😭😭 Комментарий от : @leslie760 |
Yes Nico and Siouxise. But what about Sonja from Curved Air. You want Gloom and doom. There it is in the first 2 albums!!! ❤😢❤😢❤😢 Комментарий от : @THEE4DARKESTCORNERZ23 |
It would be dope if you toyched upon the bubbling 90s electronic scene some more, but with the Chemical Brothers being a focus. 🙂 Комментарий от : @thecosmicblueautie |
It's a pity you forgot to mention Screaming Lord Sutch....He was a big pioneer of goth with his song Jack The Ripper which he did back in 1963 and dressed in white make-up, straggly hair and blacked out eyes. He is definitely a link between Screaming Jay Hawkins and Alice Cooper and deserves a mention. Frank Zappa should have also been included...There was some very dark music on their 1966 debut album 'Freak Out'... 'The return of the son of monster magnet' being one of them and 'Who needs the brain police'. Комментарий от : @barnabyhughes5643 |
Great video Комментарий от : @photorede |
Goth is in the ear of the beholder. It was a very specific London subgenere. Vaguely stating that VU and early Roxy influenced stuff applies to everything. There were many bands that clearly embraced it. But it's not just "dark". No intelligent person would label JD as goth. Their wiry guitars and serious lyrics are not goth. Ditto Siouxsie and the Cure. Post-punk is not goth. Fail. Комментарий от : @jimburesh6694 |
Ignorance won here. Комментарий от : @LoveOneAnotherHeSaid |
adult goths are a thing, they're just hiding with the rest of the silly people Комментарий от : @croozerdog-9946 |
what? no fire starter? www.youtube.com/watch?v=wmin5WkOuPw Комментарий от : @Alan-zf2tt |
Nico: i am...ugly on the inside. I promise Комментарий от : @stuartewoldt1513 |
The fact that’s is boxed in and totally stereotyped (mis stereotyped ha) shows that no one really cares about real music. I know 50yo goths who don’t even call themselves goth or new wave or whatever. They just are. People like music for the wrong reasons nowadays. That’s why they copy sounds that. Came from people who had a soul. The digital age is the reason why there are no good “goth “ bands nowadays Комментарий от : @Tupapaperro777 |
Dave Vanian credits Screaming Lord Sutch. You can bring up Jay Hawkins now but no one really got to see American acts back then (albeit Sutch was probably imitating Hawkins). I'd add in too Throbbing Gristle and Genesis P-Orridge's other works. Комментарий от : @homie3461 |
Missed out Screaming Lord Sutch and Lene Lovich Комментарий от : @stujii3986 |
I went to several Bauhaus gigs in small clubs around the UK back in the day, and I'll never forget the black-&-white strobe lighting, and watching Pete jump up from the drum platform and catch hold of the false-ceiling, he just hung there covered in shadow with his ribcage heaving, quite a moment and one I've not forgotten to this day Комментарий от : @mwudzy |
What about the industrial and synthpop cabaret voltaire? Clock DVA? Front 242? You completely ignored a massive chunk of gothic music Комментарий от : @unidentifiedhuman7639 |
Emo is Goth with less effort. Комментарий от : @trelard |
Sharing Комментарий от : @troyelliott390 |
Many interesting parallels, references, roots and relationships in music history are mentioned here. It's really fun and encourages you to rediscover influences through these cross-references. But I don't think that all these things can be clearly categorized. Most of the works mentioned here can be united by melancholy, but this is not a unique feature of 'Gothic'. Even if 'gothic' is associated with deep tones, death, transience and morbidity, for me some examples are 'simply' artistic works that express a longing, a theme, feelings or even the creation of a coherent and functioning sound and song (including performance). I wasn't a goth and I heard all that - but from an artistic point of view. 'I put a smell on you' (by Hawkins) - was a great atmospheric blues with humorous delivery. Hawkins staged himself even more and differently than his role models. Coffin & Voodoo actually became more of a humorous and ironic trademark. And even before that there were songs with depressive, melancholy content. Even popular ones. For me, 'Cramps' were free-spirited, morbid fetish surf punkers. I would also classify 'The Doors' more in the history of 'stoner rock'. With 'Bela Lugosi is dead' by 'Bauhaus', it's worth mentioning that some artists at the end of the 70's moved and released in the dark and experimental genre: The The, Coil, Yello, Soft Cell, Depeche Mode, etc., and natrl. Tubeway Army - 'Are My Friends Electric'. Bauhaus and Joy Division have also made music that is not 'gothic'. I'm still missing an assessment and classification of 'Dead Can Dance' here. Anyway, a great contribution and thank you for it!!! Комментарий от : @peffken8834 |
Why the Pixies aren’t on this list as an influence, I don’t know!?! Комментарий от : @Bexks |
Manson and all these "new era" bands, no way they would be considered Goth back in my days Комментарий от : @NapFloridian |
I played two full years in my twenties in a goth band without knowing we were a goth band. Later on after I left they started touring with Peter Murphy. Комментарий от : @Codename-B |
have no words Комментарий от : @maheshvara1984 |
Nicely done Комментарий от : @rolftaylor971 |
what do you mean by germanic?? most bands are from UK, but great watch! wish there was Sisters music ;) Комментарий от : @modechick |
What a load of utter crap. Goth was and remains a British youth cult in the same way mods, skins and punks were. It ended in the mid 80’s when goths grew up. Joy Division were never a goth band you sad muppet. Комментарий от : @Michael19841 |
I actually own a screaming Jay greatest hits with the second version of spell on you and actually love the whole cd Комментарий от : @chrismartin2966 |
Excuse me, how on earth could you have forgotten the most incredible Fields Of The Nephilim, (FOTN)????! Born in the early 80's. Carl Mc Coy the man who brought the most impressive dark tunes & Lyrics into the Goth scene, inspired mostly from the Necronomicon's book. One typical song is Psychonaut & millions more! youtu.be/CU55qip9G0A?si=KBm2PtU4jOhOoTuY youtu.be/PHIsIVB7C8A?si=T7bYENqqhKT-6Lxa And the unforgettable "Forever Remain" youtu.be/tDmFb6W4jjI?si=dCqUlxlMG5tmWHkP Комментарий от : @Necroinannacom |
Almost every Goth band is a "one tune" if not "one hit" wonder. Basically Goth is one song covered by every other Goth band. Комментарий от : @user-qk4wq5jt5q |
👁El ojo Комментарий от : @MOUBARRET |
absolutely nothing mentioned until Suicide is goth, or that goths consider goth. might as well go back to Poe and Blake and Tennyson. Комментарий от : @ToddMcKean31 |
Great video loved it im so exited to find new music there is so much great stuff out there I’m baffled I haven’t heard of a lot of it Комментарий от : @joylawes3591 |
Bauhaus & UK Decay were originators of Goth Anyone that says any band before was goth etc etc Like this video don't have a clue what they are talking about & this video is pathetic all bands etc Different genres inc from each other Комментарий от : @woody5831 |
A very nice documentary. Good work! Комментарий от : @martinandree1 |
Aparte de no citar la musica clasica funebre, faltaria comentar también el progresivo y folk oscuro de los 70's no solo del reino unido sino de otras partes del mundo. Cada pais tiene sus grupos o canciones sinestras anteriores a los 80's que pasaron desapercibidas para la mayoria de los amantes de la musica oscura por falta de conocimiento que es algo logico. Saludos Комментарий от : @agrimensork3293 |
I'm surprised there's no mention of Screaming Lord Sutch. I mean it was corny, but just watch that live video it's mad Комментарий от : @Zilegil |
This really should have mentioned Iggy Pop's album The Idiot. Комментарий от : @markrago7217 |
Nico, is the grand dame of goth. The Marble Index is the template. Комментарий от : @Fontsman-14 |
Legendary bands like The Chameleons, Sad Lovers and Giants, and the Vyllies are always criminally ignored in regards to influence and recognition. Комментарий от : @joemaldonado9231 |
For me, the darker offshoots of punk, like The Birthday Party, Sex Gang Children, Southern Death Cult, and Joy Division were the first to really embody what we'd today think of as goth Комментарий от : @dalemoss4684 |
And again everything started and has his inspiration by black music. Комментарий от : @Afterthefallout55660 |
Love this Комментарий от : @angelicaloya7006 |
This was an actual entertaining documentary, well done 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾🤙🏾✊🏾✊🏾✊🏾✊🏾 Комментарий от : @jimmybootz1277 |
Wow. Well, I know that Blue Oyster Cult was traditionally seen as a heavy metal band, but one cannot deny the amount of songs that would fall into what would be called Goth music. And this is true for most of their albums. How much influence did it have on bands that went the full Goth path... I don't know. I do know that Blue Oyster Cult left the Lovecraftian side of Goth imprinted on Metalica for one. Blue Öyster Cult (1972): Screams Tyranny and Mutation (1973): O.D.'d on Life Itself; "Mistress of the Salmon Salt (Quicklime Girl)", and even "Wings Wetted Down" when taken out of context. Secret Treaties (1974): Career of Evil, Subhuman, Harvester of Eyes, Flaming Telepaths, and Astronomy Agents of Fortune (1976): (Don't Fear) The Reaper, The Revenge of Vera Gemini, and Tattoo Vampire Spectres (1977): I Love the Night and Nosferatu Cultösaurus Erectus (1980): Black Blade, Monsters, and Unknown Tongue Fire of Unknown Origin (1981): After Dark, Joan Crawford, and Don't Turn your Back The Revölution by Night (1983): Shadow of California and Feel the Thunder Club Ninja (1985): Perfect Water Imaginos (1988): pretty much the entire album except for Del Rio's song Heaven Forbid (1998): Harvest Moon Curse of the Hidden Mirror (2001): The Old Gods Return and Out of the Darkness The Symbol Remains (2020): Tainted Blood, Nightmare Epiphany, and the Alchemist And sure, I understand that many of these songs are heavier than most Goth music, but if you listen to the music, especially, on the order songs and Imaginos, you get those Gothy sounds mixed in during the song. "Screams" for sure. And the lyrics through out have a Gothy side to them even if it often leans more toward the Lovecraftian side. And, sure, I know that the Goth movement tends to lean toward the vampire side of the supernatural influence (which Blue Oyster cult touches on a good bit as well), but it was more about the non-conformity - that is to say - breaking away from the mold of standardized acceptance like the punk movement. If one tries to fit the pattern rather than to do their own thing within the genre then one is a conformist after all and, therefore, not a non-conformist at all. Комментарий от : @jamesbarnes3832 |
MARYLIN MANSON GOTH ? HAHAHAHAH Комментарий от : @X3N0_M0RPH3 |
Dis is how goff became goff Комментарий от : @thaddeuszimmerman8242 |
Those modern "goth" bands mentioned at the end...lol...no. It's so hard to find new music these days. Комментарий от : @Jezabel-in-Hell |
Biggest mistake is defining something by description, someone decides Goth is to represent evil, someone else decides it represents the loneliness of the soul, who's going to make either of them think differently? What we decide we want something to be, that it will be because that's what it is... for us! Scream and rant in the rabbit hole as much as you want, one man's rabbit hole is another man's rabbit stew if you get my drift, don't care what anyone else says. Комментарий от : @normancherry8732 |
Just thank the punk movement for the origin of everything and move on Комментарий от : @Silentkat1975 |
I think more than goth music becoming different, the umbrella of what could be considered “goth rock” has expanded further, where it can incorporate more pop punk/emo music, or maybe more atmospheric folk, or lean more into hard rock and heavy metal(etc), but there are still some bands that maintain a classic goth feel, even down to the production, like Molchat Doma or Desmond Doom. Though my personal favorites in the modern scene tend to be on the heavier side like Tribulation or Unto Others. Комментарий от : @SkullandSwors_art |
All the music I like - but I am not “a goth” - I am a lover a great music Комментарий от : @daveleafey9283 |
Very good video. While Krautrock is briefly mentioned, I think Neu! should have been given some time as one of the bands profiled, or perhaps both Neu! and Can. "Negativland" from Neu's self-titled debut and both "Hero" and "E-musick" from Neu! 75 should most definitely be included in the canon of proto-post-punk. Комментарий от : @fisherwebdev |
I dunno wtf you're talking about with that 1st part and Screaming Joe Hawkins Комментарий от : @tylerkeller8869 |
Like dark humor with great comedians, it's not most can't do it, they just won't. Zombies - She's Not There and Kinks- Sunny Afternoon hit close. Of course, this conversation doesn't mean crap without the VU. Комментарий от : @howamilooking5952 |
1- Nothing Gothic nor talented about these clowns and their extremely UNlistenable music like there is nothing Christian in marxists, but quite the contrary really. 2- Their ''act'' all part of the same commie playbook to weaken America from within focusing on manipulating the young to submitting to the ever so foreign for anti American marxism 3- Just and justly remember what ex KGB Bezmenov revealed about their Sex, Drugs and Rock and Roll mantra ofcommies who pivoted to China when the USSR imploded by the weight of its own oppression and mediocrity. 4-Listen to what Bezmenov said for good realizing them rock robolutionaries as crappers of where they eat, scripted and planted by a continuos kabal wanting the people to ''own nothing and be UNhappy'' when they, the elites pulling the strings behind it all get to own everythin, God forbid, after succeeding in social engineering American into their ''happy slaves'' or else... 5- Reality sucks and worse to let theses suckers keep on trying to fool you . It's time to wake up to the reality that they' ve been scientifically and methodically setting Americans up for failure big , the arSONists while acting and playing firefighters with this ''Gothic'' gimmicky shtick too, that is as phony as their love of freedom , of the democratic ways and of the noble ideals of America as enshrined in its Constitution and The Bills of Rights...both under attack for a long time from within. 5-Shema!!! Комментарий от : @alexstewart8097 |
This video Water 70% Land 30% Комментарий от : @MD-fp5fy |
Evanescence is worthy of mention Комментарий от : @deathlarsen7502 |
I got to see Cooper this summer. He still puts on a hell of a show! Комментарий от : @a88aiello |
Its a pity that noone ever talks about postpunkrock "The Sound" with their album "Sound out of a Lions mouth". Such a great album never talked about. Комментарий от : @fk-hi6gs |
Seeing Alice Cooper live was one of the greatest things I have ever experienced. He's a wonderful showman Комментарий от : @epicentr00m |
I like all these bands but recently I've been hearing alot of Cocteau Twins. Never heard much of their music. It is very interesting to me. Ty for this post it was really good. Комментарий от : @Kozak-ys8cb |
Awesome! I love to hear the history of musical genres. Goth wouldn't be Goth without the music. Liked and subscribed! Комментарий от : @RyansCustomShopandGearOutlet |
NIN should be in this video too, they are most important gothic/industrial band in the 90's, even Bowie and Cash knews it, hurt is the darkness hymn of generation X, pigs, march to the pigs, something i can never have, terrible lie. There's nothing most dark and morbid than record an album in the house where actress Sharon Tate was murdered by Manson family in 1969. Комментарий от : @danielsoares7456 |
I love that you touched on Suicide. Hadnt thought of them in a long time. This whole list is great and perfect. Комментарий от : @cheapthrilll6323 |
OS REIS DA MÚSICA GOTICA BAUHAUS Комментарий от : @pedrocorrea5563 |